PEG: "Please keep in mind that SD5 does not have the reasoning skills to steal. She is not being malicious merely 5. Just teach her to respect others belongings. She Does not know the value of jewelry or money yet. Enjoy them!
DH: "SD5 told me that she put the jewelry in SD9's purse because she was trying to get SD9 in trouble. She said SD9 was being mean to her. She may not know the value of the items, but she clearly knew that what she was doing was wrong. She
was being malicious. I have addressed this and other problematic behavior, and they are being punished. They will call you tomorrow."
PEG: "she is five that is normal behavior."
I'm gonna go with...
no, it's not. Spilling the milk and saying she doesn't know how it got knocked over? That's normal. Breaking her sister's toy and saying she didn't do it? That's normal. Fake-crying for attention? That's normal. Dropping a hulking deuce in the toilet, not flushing, and then blaming it on the dog? That's actually pretty normal for SD5, too.
Opening my bedroom door, walking to my jewelry box, taking several piece of jewelry, sneaking back into her bedroom, stashing the jewelry in her sister's purse because she was mad that her sister was being mean to her, and then waiting patiently for her sister to get spanked when the purse was opened?
That's not.... umm... normal. I've never met a 5-year-old who could craft such an elaborate revenge plot and actually keeping the whole thing secret until it played out.
I love the anti-logic here, though.
First PEG sends an unprompted text announcing that SD5 had no reasoning skills and was not being malicious. PEG knows this because she is a mind-reader.
When confronted with SD5’s own admission that she was quite clearly being malicious (aside from her reasoning skills being shockingly advanced to plot and execute this plan to get her sister in trouble), PEG completely reverses her tactics and enables the behavior by dismissing it as “normal.”
Children might not respect boundaries at that age, and they may have very little concept of “valuables.” They make mistakes, and they do things that are wrong and hurtful. But if you dismiss those mistakes as “normal childhood behavior,” it will eventually turn into “antisocial adult behavior.”
Omfg, you moron. Let’s give SD5 a cookie for all her efforts.
"Enjoy them!"
Fuck you.