Book Review: Stop Walking On Eggshells
Have your own psycho ex? Get a FREE Report on "Why Co-Parenting Doesn't Work", or learn how to win child custody with a custody coach.
Stop Walking on Eggshells: Taking Your Life Back When Someone You Care about Has Borderline Personality Disorder
by Authors: Paul T. Mason and Randi Kreger
———-
After having read this amazingly insightful book which gives a methodical look into the root causes of borderline personality disorder and the associated effects it has on the sufferer’s life and those who have attempted to have relationships with them, I am put in a position to present two separate reviews of Stop Walking On Eggshells. One review is of the creation and development of the borderline personality disorder. The second review is of the suggestions offered to the non-sufferers in managing their relationship, should they choose to do so, with the person who has this devastating disorder.
Authors Mason and Kreger likely could not have done better in breaking down borderline personality disorder; from its origins in the patient’s childhood through the chaos and terror that they suffer and perpetrate on others into and throughout adulthood. They provide invaluable information to the reader by identifying the behaviors, symptoms, and traits of the borderline person. Mason and Kreger do a terrific job of breaking down the DSM-IV diagnostic criteria into understandable language. If you have a relationship of any kind with a person suffering from BPD, this book could be considered second-to-none in helping you understand why they behave the way they do. Having suffered for more than 12-years (ongoing in the aftermath of divorce with children) – it was somewhat of a relief to find out that I really wasn’t going insane. I was not the cause of her drama and chaos. My often intense level of confusion left me questioning my own mental health and, at times, what was reality. Of particular interest where the excerpts of the thoughts and feelings of both the BPD and non-BPD throughout this book. If you’ve suffered such intense abuse at the hands of a BPD, their “thoughts” about how they feel and how they should be treated or understood can be a bit unnerving. Conversely, you will find some measure of relief as the non-BPDs recount their feelings and experiences.
In that regard, this book is a must-have if you need a comprehensive understanding of the person you’ve encountered who is or may be suffering from borderline personality disorder.
The second part of my review must be read with consideration that I’ve had a long-term and ongoing relationship with a now ex-spouse who I strongly suspect of suffering from BPD. I say that simply because she has never been professionally diagnosed.
If you’ve had any level of experience with a BPD sufferer, there is a lot in this book that will strike you as “easier said than done.” Worse, it might make you feel as the BPD made you feel - like you aren’t or weren’t good enough to handle the situation that confronted you so intensely. You may be offended.
Perhaps I was expecting a more sympathetic view towards the non-borderline and what I was met with were suggestions and coping mechanisms that were without a true sense of the level of suffering that has been levied upon the non-BPD. If this is you - the way in which these suggestions are delivered could rise to the level of offensive. If this is not you, it will be viewed with a vastly different understanding. The difficulty in practical application of these techniques is something that you couldn’t possibly fathom without having been “in the trenches” yourself. Offering a BPD’s viewpoint about how a non-BPD should be more understanding of their suffering and how to better handle them is tantamount to a perpetrator of torture telling their victim to understand better why they do what they do and how to accept it.
I strongly believe that Paul Mason and Randi Kreger needed to do a better job of conveying to readers that the “matter of fact” delivery of suggested methods of dealing with a borderline are impractical in day-to-day application and virtually impossible to achieve with a BPD when you are “under fire.” I know that this description sounds dramatic, but those who have been there would understand that language completely. I know psychologists who refuse to work with people having borderline personality disorder because of their level of chaotic, terroristic, and incredibly manipulative behavior. To expect an untrained person to handle it well under the circumstances is unrealistic. I also understand that there are those who don’t necessarily have a choice to avoid dealing with a BPD, for example, parents of a child with BPD. For those folks, these suggestions could prove to be a life preserver of sorts.
Overall, for a complete understanding of the development of borderline personality disorder, the impact on the sufferer, and the impact on those around the sufferer, this book should be at or near the top of your list.
~LM


January 27th, 2008 at 6:14 pm
I have never read the book you have just reviewed or the one that I often hear suggested which is “I hate you, don’t leave me” but I am glad to hear that it seems to offer insights into the BPD mind which will promote understanding and hopefully reduce the stigma that this disorder carries in society. It was a good review and I thinking of picking up a copy for myself.
January 27th, 2008 at 7:41 pm
Thank you for your review and for validating my feelings!:)
I do have the book in my library, mostly because everyone was telling me I needed to read it. So, I got a copy.
I was incredibly offended at times when reading the book. I felt I(the sane non in the relationship) was almost expected to be Christ himself–the expectations of the non seemed to be excessivly high.
I thought it was just me being overly sensitive though.
Interesting read, but nons beware, don’t take it too personally.
Thanks for this review.
January 28th, 2008 at 1:58 am
Obviously, my comments are tempered by the understanding that people are in various places in their understanding/involvement with the BPD.
My personal takeaway was one less of being offended as simply saying (sometimes out loud to DW) - “The suggestions for dealing/coping are nice in theory, but the truth is it takes a level of patience and understanding that most people probably don’t have!” Again, that is assuming that the vitriol and hate-spew are similar to what I experienced.
For those of you who have read the book - can you imagine, having read what you have already of my real-life interactions with PEW, imagine having the patience to perform what amounts to reflective-therapy with a raging BPD, even if I was aware of the disorder?
I can’t.
January 28th, 2008 at 3:09 am
No, I can’t imagine Mr. M. I think though, that patience isn’t the only thing the authors assume you have limitless amounts of.
It is absolutely and utterly exhausing physically, mentally and emotionally to deal with a BPD. That’s not even thinking about the “normal” stress we all deal with either.. Then, to boot, you are supposed to be able to summon the energy to take on the craziness? It’s not even remotely possible.
But I am cynical….it would be a pretty short book if all they had to say was “RUN AWAY…..NOW!”, wouldn’t it?
January 28th, 2008 at 4:01 am
What ‘Eggshells’ did for me was finally identify what we were dealing with. It was such a relief to realize that we really weren’t the crazy ones! Reading it was like watching a puzzle put itself together.
“Splitting” gave us a legal game plan.
January 28th, 2008 at 4:03 am
Splitting is next on our review list.
November 2nd, 2008 at 10:54 am
[...] my psycho ex wife; but the whole scenario was horribly familiar. I got a book you recommended–“Stop Walking on Eggshells”–and . . . it was kind of like the scales falling from my eyes. It was a weird [...]
November 4th, 2008 at 1:37 am
I found “Splitting” to be an excellent read as well.
June 11th, 2009 at 6:37 pm
I recently picked up this book on the advice of a psychologist. I was seeking advice on how to deal with my mother. Having not been the spouse of a BP, I probably am not as bitter as someone who chose to love someone who treats them in such a way. But I see their non-BP view approach as short-term. As in, this is what you should do to survive until you can get them to get help. I can’t see their advice as being a long-term solution, even if that is how it’s meant. I would hope not.
July 7th, 2009 at 12:42 pm
[...] did read and review Stop Walking on Eggshells. (Click the link to read it, I recommended [...]
September 12th, 2009 at 10:18 pm
[...] To read my book review of Stop Walking on Eggshells: CLICK HERE. [...]